Case 40 : DONOR INTEGRITY
Challenges
A group of medical students discusses the ethical acceptability of organ transplants. Some maintain that donating an organ does not in any way help the donor; rather, it even poses some risk, whether during the operation or in the future. Furthermore, it involves the mutilation of a perfectly functioning body part.
Question
What are some ethical principles that allow organ donation, despite its disadvantages to the donor?
Solutions
Before the 1950’s organ transplants between living persons remained generally not technically feasible. At that time ethical discussions tended to disapprove of organ donation, given their focus on the principle of totality and integrity. This principle states that deliberate mutilation or injury to one part of the body is justified only if it is done to preserve the person’s own health or life (e.g., a gangrenous foot undergoes amputation); such is not the case in organ donation, when a perfectly functioning organ is removed.
Discussions then tried to search for other principles that could justify donation. One such principle is fraternal love, or charity. In other areas of life, a person sacrifice time, efforts and resources out of love towards another – even to the point of causing some discomfort or harm on oneself (e.g., entering a burning house to save a baby). Similarly, then, the person may sacrifice a bodily part, provided, however, only limited harm befalls the donor. But doesn’t this reasoning still go against the principle of totality and integrity?
To answer this question, a distinction was made between anatomical integrity (or material or physical integrity) and functional integrity (or physiological integrity), pointing out the absolute necessity of the latter but not of the former. A missing kidney would mean a loss of anatomical integrity, but since the other kidney compensates for the necessary physiological functions, functional integrity is still maintained. Thus, kidney donation is acceptable. On the other hand, donating a heart valve or a cornea is not acceptable because it would mean destroying both anatomical and functional integrity.
Thus, an organ donation motivated by fraternal charity is acceptable as long as the donor’s functional integrity is maintained, even if some anatomical integrity is lost.





